The em dash is not a red flag; it’s a beat that a comma can’t land

Scanning copy for em dashes like they're evidence of AI? Let's be honest about what that is. It's lazy. The same kind of lazy as writers who let AI write for them without thinking. You're just doing it from the other side of the page.

Here's what happens. Before AI, I barely used em dashes. They just weren't on my radar. I'd use a comma where an em dash would have been useful — without knowing it.

Then I started working with AI and noticed: it uses them. Consistently, cleanly, correctly. A soft stop before a pivot. A way to pull your eye to what matters. A beat that a comma can't quite land.

That's brilliant. So I learned from it. Made a keyboard shortcut for the em dash. That's what you do when something earns its place.

The writers not using em dashes to avoid suspicion? They're letting AI dictate their style.

Don't judge copy by an em dash

Overuse is the signal. Five em dashes in three paragraphs, none of them earning their place. That's automation, not writing.

A few, used with intent? That's a writer paying attention. Caring and crafting. Making choices. Knowing when to stop, pivot, and let the point land.

The real problem is you

When punctuation becomes your fastest shortcut to a verdict, that's not detection. That's the loss of critical reading. You've replaced the ability to recognize craft with the ability to spot patterns.

That's the real problem. Not the em dash.

Read the writing. Not the punctuation.

About my confessions

More about me and my confessions. Why I hold content to a higher standard. And why I write what most people in this industry won't say out loud.

I'm a content strategist with a university background in marketing, media, sociology, and psychology. I've worked in this industry for 25+ years and for 50+ global brands and agencies. 

I've seen a lot. Made many mistakes. Learned even more. 

Now, I share all this to inspire everyone working in marketing and communication to more accountable work. There's already too much crappy content out there; no need to add to it.

Join 2,500+ professionals

Most content advice tells you what to do. This tells you how to think. For marketers and communicators who want the difference. 

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

→ Subscribe